Sunday, March 17, 2024

Amazon's Troll Farm?

 

 

 

What is Fiction?

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fiction

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/fiction

the type of book or story that is written about imaginary characters and events and not based on real people and facts:

https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/fiction

A fiction is a deliberately fabricated account of something. It can also be a literary work based on imagination rather than on fact, like a novel or short story.

https://www.amazon.com/Ankhesenamun-Queen-Egypt-Michael-Costa/dp/1466406666/

This historical-fiction novel written in 1992 chronicles the lives of late 18th Dynasty Egypt, those of Tutankhamun and his wife, Queen Ankhesenamun. An Excerpt: Commander Horemhab sat anxiously and impatiently on the floor of his chariot, waiting for an answer. The royal troops had aligned the entrance of the Nubian camp and several scouts were patrolling in and out of the enemy head-quarters, looking for their leader. A single chariot of Nubian craftsmanship, originally stolen from Egyptian garrisons and modified to meet their standards, shifted the desert sands behind it as the chariot entered through an unprotected gap in the Egyptian wall of horses. A proud announcement saluted the commander from afar, and this caused him to rise from his seat. It was Tutankhamon. Excited, Horemhab shouted to the sky in adoration of the god Horus, relieved that his prayers had been answered. Horemhab exalted his comrades over the news. Ay was the first to respond. "It couldn't be him; that charioteer looks nothing like Tutankhamon." Tut removed his wig and Ay looked closer. "Oh my god." Copyright 2004, 2011 Michael J. Costa, All rights reserved.

A Trolled Review on Amazon:

This is a self-published book written in the early 90s and published in the 2000s. It's pretty full of itself and pretentious in that sense, not to mention woefully historically inaccurate due to those dates.

It is not very well written, I bought it used thank goodness, paying full price for this dreck would be sad. The formatting is off-putting and sloppy, the characters aren't well written, it just has an air of "no one helped me write this." In fact it ends with the author thanking no one and providing no research sources. What a surprise.

Alright lets start this.

The dialogue is stiff and lacking in creativity, for example: "I don't like to see the tears fall from your lovely eyes. That makes me feel upset." If you've ever taken a creative writing class or had an editor, you would know that you don't have characters exclaim their emotions so poorly.

One section just jumps to another with a simple three word sentence: "some months passed." Everything is just so poorly paced! "-led by his wife into the celebration already in progress" THE VERY NEXT PARAGRAPH AND SENTENCE: "later, the celebration dwindled." We as the audience and reader get nothing.

I could be an editor on this for hours it's just so bad. Half of it is so funny though due to its problems, there's a scene where characters fight for not even five sentences and it ends with, "this action resulted in a large quarrel, which left Tut disadvantaged and powerless." Then: "meanwhile Queen Tiye died." I can't- I am not even joking.

Not to mention the complete lack of detail involving anything Egyptian. No gods are explained, no rituals are explained, no nothing. There is detail but it picks and chooses when to do so and even then its only in item descriptions and speech. One character used “totally”, this book is a hot mess. Some gods are given Greek names, some names are horribly misspelled. Just...ugh.

The book is written from the view of Tut's soul, so that way the writer can info dump random current historical nonsense that rips you out of the story. This is also how the story ends, with Tut's soul watching history unfold cause the author loves Carter so much. Also, the book is called “Ankhesenamun: Queen of Egypt” yet it’s about Tut and his spirit. Just...why???

I love ancient Egypt and I picked up this book for my collection as it's a very niche genre, I did so that no one else has to do the same. Do yourself a favor and skip this book, as others have put in more thought and care into their writing that are worth a read.

This author needs a reality check, using his “mystical connection“ to write is just insulting.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/profile/amzn1.account.AGCIVRTCL7JJUG647GOHL73NLRJA/ref=cm_cr_dp_d_gw_tr?ie=UTF8

MC 2024.


 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment